For decades, Gore-Tex has dominated the market as the go-to material for waterproofing outdoor apparel, but in recent years competitors have stepped up their game.
This article aims to shed light on the Gore-Tex versus non-Gore-Tex debate, exploring the benefits, drawbacks, and advancements in waterproofing technologies.
So put on your waterproof boots and let´s pour over this question…
The Reign of Gore-Tex
In 1969, a serendipitous discovery by Robert W. Gore, a chemical engineer, would forever change the world of outdoor gear.
While experimenting with the polymer polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), he accidentally created an expanded and highly porous structure by stretching the material. This innovative breakthrough laid the foundation for what would become known as Gore-Tex.
With the support of his family, Robert W. Gore, along with his parents Wilbert L. Gore and Genevieve, delved further into the possibilities of this new material. They soon realized its extraordinary properties: it was remarkably lightweight, and waterproof, and boasted an exceptional ability to allow water vapor to pass through while blocking liquid water. This combination made it a perfect candidate for waterproof and breathable outdoor apparel.
After years of rigorous research and development, W.L. Gore & Associates officially introduced Gore-Tex to the world in 1976. Initially, it found applications in the medical field, particularly for creating improved vascular grafts. However, it didn’t take long for the outdoor industry to recognize the potential of Gore-Tex for outdoor clothing and gear.
Outdoor enthusiasts, athletes, and professionals quickly embraced Gore-Tex as the ultimate solution to staying dry and comfortable in wet and challenging environments. Hikers, mountaineers, skiers, and adventurers of all kinds found that Gore-Tex allowed them to push their limits without worrying about getting soaked in rain or snow.
Over time, Gore-Tex became more than just a brand; it became synonymous with top-tier waterproofing and breathability in the outdoor industry. While competitors attempted to develop their waterproof materials, Gore-Tex’s advanced technology and commitment to innovation allowed it to maintain its dominance in the market.
For over 40+ years, Gore-Tex has become a household name, and it is often the first name that springs to mind when outdoor adventures are looking for some new waterproof goodies. As much as Goretex represents quality, it also represents a higher price tag than its competitors, leaving us to wonder if other brands have similar quality products at a lower price.
Pros of Gore-Tex
- Waterproof: Gore-Tex effectively repels rain, snow, and moisture, keeping the wearer dry in most conditions.
- Breathability: The microporous structure allows sweat vapor to escape, reducing internal condensation and keeping the wearer comfortable.
- Durability: High-quality Gore-Tex fabrics are renowned for their longevity and resistance to wear and tear.
- Established Reputation: Gore-Tex has stood the test of time and earned a reputation for reliable waterproofing in extreme environments.
Cons of Gore-Tex
- Cost: Gore-Tex technology is relatively expensive to produce, which can result in higher-priced products for consumers. This premium pricing may not be feasible for budget-conscious individuals or those looking for more affordable options.
- No Universal Standard: Not all Gore-Tex products are created equal. The range of Gore-Tex fabrics varies, and some may prioritize waterproofing over breathability, while others may prioritize the opposite. This lack of a universal standard can make it challenging for consumers to compare products and make informed choices.
- Environmental Concerns: The manufacturing process of PTFE-based materials like Gore-Tex involves the use of fluorocarbons, which are potent greenhouse gases. While efforts are being made to address this issue, environmental concerns related to the production and disposal of Gore-Tex products persist.
Products Containing Gore-Tex Technology
These days you can find almost every piece of outdoor clothing with Gore-Tex waterproofing. Including:
- Outdoor Jackets: Gore-Tex is commonly used in rain jackets, hiking jackets, ski jackets, snowboard jackets, and mountaineering shells.
- Pants and Trousers: Gore-Tex can be found in waterproof pants and trousers designed for various outdoor activities.
- Footwear: Hiking boots, trekking shoes, trail running shoes, and some types of sneakers may incorporate Gore-Tex waterproofing to keep your feet dry during wet conditions.
- Gloves and Mittens: Waterproof and breathable gloves are often made with Gore-Tex technology for winter sports and other outdoor activities.
- Backpacks and Bags: Some outdoor backpacks and bags may feature Gore-Tex technology to provide weather resistance and protect your gear.
- Hats and Headwear: Gore-Tex can be used in hats and headwear to offer protection against rain and snow.
- Tents and Shelter Systems: High-quality camping tents and shelter systems may utilize Gore-Tex to enhance their waterproofing capabilities.
- Gaiters: Waterproof gaiters designed to keep snow, mud, and debris out of your shoes may incorporate Gore-Tex for added protection.
- Workwear: Certain workwear and occupational apparel may use Gore-Tex to provide workers with protection from the elements while on the job.
Gore-Tex´s Assurance Of Quality
The brand has done well to ensure that its logo and technology are always used on high-quality products. This time and again has proven its worth and is the reason why they are one of the most highly regarded brands in the outdoor sports industry.
Gore-Tex ensures quality when used by other brands through a controlled licensing process.
Brands seeking to use Gore-Tex technology must enter into a licensing agreement with W.L. Gore & Associates. The process involves rigorous testing and certification of products to meet Gore’s performance standards for waterproofness, breathability, and durability.
Brands must adhere to specific guidelines for material sourcing, production, and quality control. Gore maintains close collaboration with licensees to uphold its brand reputation and deliver consistent performance across products, ensuring consumers can trust the waterproof and breathable capabilities of Gore-Tex regardless of the brand.
We believe this is one of the main reasons that Gor-Tex has stood tall above all other waterproof trademarks who come and go through the years.
Brands That Use Gore-Tex In their Products
Along with Gore-Tex´s brand of outdoor clothing – Gore Wear. Gore-Tex technologies are licensed out to some of the biggest sports and outdoor adventure brands in the game, who often use the material in their high-end models, alongside the brands’ technologies.
Some of the brands that use Gote-Tex are:
- The North Face
- Mountain Hardwear
- Outdoor Research
- Helly Hansen
- Black Diamond
- La Sportiva
Is Gore-Tex Worth The Price?
If you are an adventurer who often finds yourself in poor weather conditions for longer periods of time, you need durable, waterproof clothing that offers warmth and comfort. In this case, in our opinion Gore-Tex is 100% worth the investment.
If you are a weekend warrior, who only enjoys the outdoors when the sun is out or are looking for a waterproof item to walk the dog. You will prob get away with something cheaper.
Gore-Tex offers top-notch waterproofing and breathability, making it ideal for intense outdoor activities and challenging weather conditions.
The decision to invest in Gore-Tex or explore alternatives should be based on the frequency of use, activities, and the importance placed on high-performance gear. Ultimately, whether Gore-Tex is worth the price depends on personal priorities and the value placed on its exceptional waterproofing and breathability capabilities.
The Rise of Alternatives
In recent years, the outdoor industry has witnessed the rise of alternative waterproofing technologies, challenging the long-standing dominance of Gore-Tex.
As the competition intensifies, manufacturers are continually refining their products to address the limitations of traditional waterproofing materials. The rise of alternatives to Gore-Tex has not only expanded the options available to outdoor enthusiasts but also driven innovation in the quest for the perfect balance of waterproofing, breathability, durability, and environmental sustainability.
As companies continue to innovate, several notable alternatives have emerged, offering different approaches to waterproof and breathable performance.
Here are some of the rising alternatives to Gore-Tex:
eVent is a direct competitor to Gore-Tex, offering a proprietary waterproof and breathable membrane technology.
Its key differentiator is its “dry” system, which uses a unique process to disperse moisture, providing excellent breathability even during intense physical activity.
Developed by Polartec, NeoShell is designed to bridge the gap between waterproofing and breathability. It uses a combination of a microporous membrane and air-permeable face fabric, enabling dynamic air exchange and enhanced comfort in various conditions.
Created by The North Face, DryVent is a versatile waterproof fabric available in multiple variants for different activity levels and weather conditions.
It features a polyurethane (PU) coating with a multilayer formula to provide reliable waterproofing and breathability.
Hailing from Japan, Dermizax is another popular alternative to Gore-Tex. It is known for its stretchiness, making it suitable for athletic and dynamic movements. Dermizax boasts high waterproof and breathability ratings, making it a preferred choice for ski and snowboard apparel.
Sympatex utilizes a hydrophilic, non-porous membrane that is 100% recyclable and free of PTFE. It offers high waterproof and windproof performance, with an emphasis on environmental sustainability.
Developed by Patagonia, H2No® is a versatile waterproof, and breathable technology designed for outdoor enthusiasts. The technology includes both 2.5-layer and 3-layer constructions to provide varying levels of protection and performance.
Introduced by The North Face, Futurelight is a revolutionary fabric that uses nano spinning technology to create a waterproof and breathable membrane. It promises enhanced breathability and improved environmental sustainability compared to traditional waterproof materials.
So, Should I go For Gore-Tex Or A Competitor?
The decision between Gore-Tex and a competitor ultimately depends on your specific needs, preferences, and budget.
Both Gore-Tex and its alternatives offer waterproofing and breathability, but they may vary in terms of performance, price, and other features.
Here are some factors to consider when making your choice:
Consider the primary purpose of the gear you need. Will you be engaging in high-intensity activities like mountaineering or skiing, or do you require waterproofing for casual outdoor use? Different activities may demand varying levels of waterproofing and breathability.
Gore-Tex is known for its high-quality performance but often comes with a higher price tag compared to some alternatives. If cost is a significant concern, you may find competitive brands that offer similar waterproofing performance at a more affordable price.
Take into account the reputation of both Gore-Tex and the competitor brands you are considering. Research user reviews and feedback to assess the reliability and performance of the products.
Climate and Conditions
Consider the typical weather and environmental conditions in which you’ll be using the gear.
If you frequently encounter heavy rain or snow, you might prioritize materials with higher waterproof ratings. On the other hand, if you plan to engage in highly aerobic activities, breathability becomes crucial.
Evaluate the specific features offered by each brand and its materials. Some alternatives may provide additional benefits like enhanced stretch, lightweight properties, or specialized designs for particular activities.
Fit and Comfort
Fit and comfort are subjective, and different materials may feel different against your skin. Whenever possible, try on different products to see which one feels most comfortable and suits your body shape.
Keep in mind that some companies may offer products with a combination of materials, utilizing both Gore-Tex and alternative technologies to achieve the best performance in various areas.
The choice between Gore-Tex and alternative waterproofing technologies depends on individual preferences, intended use, and budget.
Gore-Tex has long been the gold standard in the outdoor industry, offering reliable waterproofing and breathability. Its reputation for quality and performance has made it synonymous with top-tier gear for outdoor enthusiasts.
However, the rise of alternative technologies has introduced competition, providing consumers with more options to suit their specific needs. Brands like eVent, NeoShell, DryVent, Dermizax, and others offer varying features and benefits, such as improved breathability, cost-effectiveness, or specialized applications.
When making a decision, it is crucial to consider the intended use of the gear, budget constraints, brand reputation, and environmental considerations. Ultimately, both Gore-Tex and its competitors have their merits, and the best choice depends on personal preferences and the specific demands of your outdoor activities.
Thanks for reading.
Other Helpful Articles
If you found this article helpful you will love these too!